The extent of Chinese forward planning

Chinas five-year plans are the closest thing to an election manifesto for the Communist Party, laying out its longer-term priorities. But since the party still has overwhelming power, the plans carry real weight and China has a way of following through on most its goals.

Understanding the goals is important in understanding China. All major players—local officials, banks and big companies, both state-owned and private—change their strategies and their rhetoric to be in line with the plans. Therefore, the players do the work of the Government due to what is incentivised. The fact that companies do the bidding of the government is the outcome of Chinas “Pluralistic Society”.


Our thesis is that China has been staging a deliberate slowdown to maintain the longevity of its growth.  Most forget that growth of 6+% is still significant – and even at this level there is a strain on any economy – specifically in the cost of inputs. Growing pains are inevitable. It is true we aren’t in the heady days of double-digit percentage GDP growth, but the dollar growth in GDP of the world’s second biggest economy is massive.

Chinas Natural Growth Rate

Although we believe China is slowing its growth, we still believe its natural growth rate is 2-3 times the published rate. We expect the engineered slowdown could take natural growth to more like 12% to 18% in the coming years.  Growth for the sake of growth is a Western concept.

Lowering Input Prices

What is critical for China is export competitiveness. If our thesis is right and China has been engineering a deliberate and graduated slow down then the effect will be to lower input prices (eg commodities and wages). This will keep their exports more competitive.

The slowing so far has lead to instability and uncertainty in international markets – which the Chinese have been adept at taking advantage of.

Some unemployment is desirable.  For several years Chinese wage demands rose, as did demands for improved working conditions. On the ground in China some locals are out of work due to the slowdown and (anecdotally) some workers are returning to the regional farms. This leads to lower pressure on wages as people wont be asking for better pay and conditions anytime soon. Therefore export prices remain competitive.

Building a Nation

The modus operandi of China is to build a nation. In so doing it uses so much of the worlds resources (including Australias commodities). But to do this successfully it cant have the rest of the world being too strong or too weak – as this impacts on their own success. This creates a delicate balance for China.

This moderation of growth is more sustainable for China’s industrialisation. There is no pressure on them to create growth for the sake of growth. They are building a nation, not reporting to shareholders. This is alien to Westerners who are governed by capitalism and the need for maximum growth with boom and bust cycles.

For the East, managing the growth so they can build a nation is common sense. There is a cultural divide which is impossible for Westerners to understand – its literally like fitting a round peg in a square hole. Eastern philosophy is long term by nature whereas Western philosophy is NOT. Short term thinking is indoctrinated in our markets.

Where economic rationality is expected and not delivered due to reasons such as these it leads to investment mistakes.  This is a key area maths has a role to play – seeing through the noise and getting to the heart of the share price behaviour.  This means we are able to buy when people are most fearful – mathematically taking advantage of the opportunity created through panic.  Pythagoras is based on our Volatility Index which changes ahead of share price changes.  This allows Pythagoras to recommend buying and selling accordingly – in advance of the share price behaviour.  The returns are remarkable. 

If this interests you please call Michael 0419726

Disclaimer: The information in this document (“Information”) is not intended to constitute advice. It is for general information only and does not take into account your individual objectives, financial situation or needs. You should assess whether the information is appropriate for you and seek professional financial advice before relying on or making investment decisions based on the Information. Investment products are subject to risk including the loss of income or capital invested. Past performance is not an indicator of future performance. Neither Pythagoras Investment Timing Index Pty Ltd ACN 147371113 (AFSL 431 238), its directors, employees and representatives (collectively, “Pythagoras”) warrant the accuracy or completeness of the Information. To the extent permitted by law, Pythagoras disclaims all responsibility and liability for any loss or damage of any nature whatsoever which may be suffered by any person directly or indirectly.